Nisimazine
Monday 4 June 10:16contact us | partners and links
Home page > Review > Navidad (28 May 2009)
Review
[en]

Navidad by Sebastiàn Lelio

Chile / France  
Navidad
© MC Films

More than strictly a movie, this film is a sort of glimpse through the hole that the director has carved into the wall of a country house where a young couple is spending New Year’s Eve. But far from being interested, the spectator ends up tired, feeling a sense of watching nothing but their lack of communication and damaged intimacy. The dialogues are these but they could perfectly well be any others, any other silly conversation; few things make sense in this strange exercise which fails to stimulate us. We hardly get involved with the characters and can’t help feeling like voyeurs of a tasteless show.

This young couple is spending a weekend in an empty house, but apparently, not because of love or friendship, just because she wants to find a box with old records which had belonged to her father - and maybe with the pretext that the Christmas of the title is a moment when people come together, since the filmmaker has stated that he wanted to use Catholic references. But they have very little in common. Only when a younger girl appears on the scene does a weird relationship begin to arise in the group. Insipid anecdotes, plus simple and unoriginal camera movements, make this film more than dispensable.

Andrea Franco

contact the author print this article Save this article in PDF Send this article by mail post a comment other languages


Follow-up of the site's activity RSS 2.0 | Site Map | Login | credits & special mentions | www.nisimasa.com

Site internet: A.L, creation site internet, graphiste freelance.