Nisimazine
Friday 10 February 08:27contact us | partners and links
Home page > Review > Below Sea Level (10 March 2009)
Review
[en]

Below Sea Level by Gianfranco Rosi

Italy/USA (2008)  
Below Sea Level
copyright "21 One Productions", 2008

Although I’d never been to the Southwest of the United States, I was kind of sure I knew what it was like. The Coen Brothers’, Wim Wenders and others created such a diverse image of it, that I was sure the truth was somewhere in between all that. So when I saw Gianfranco Rosi’s Below Sea Level, it was surprising to get not only a new perspective on this region of the most filmed country in the world, but also on life in general.

In the middle of the Californian nowhere, in a desert far away from civilisation, a bunch of stranded individuals form an obscure community. There are no houses, electricity or water, no government, and no cops, but you can find a beauty salon and a pet-graveyard. Some of the people who live there are looking for freedom and security outside the towns, but most of them just want to forget.

Some kind of personal disaster brought each of them here on their own. Yet although everyone is seeking the healing power of solitude, their paths cross and they become neighbours, friends and lovers – not without keeping a certain distance, being unable to overcome protective mechanism of distrust learned over the years. Some of our protagonists’ stories get told, some remain unsaid.

It’s especially fascinating to discover how ‘Bus Kenny’, Lili the doctor, ‘Bulletproof’ and the others developed their own strategies to face life and how they created their own theories on existence and fate. When ‘Insane Wayne’ - the community’s ‘late Nietzsche’ - talks about killing god, while his friend Mike comments “Life is good - the only thing that bothers me is mice” we understand that Below Sea Level is also a philosophical film - about the philosophy of the unfortunates, the failed ones.

Although we gain extremely intimate insights into these people’s lives, the camera is far from voyeuristic or sensation-seeking. It just feels truthful, real. A refreshing experience in times of pseudo-fiction, mockumentaries, documentary-soaps and other dilutions.

In fact we don’t pay too much attention to understanding how Rosi placed the camera in especially delicate situations or how he made his protagonists forget the camera, we just want to listen to these people who seem so strong. So much so that we have to be careful not to be dragged in by a certain romanticism of their situation – that of life Below Sea Level.

Overall, a remarkable film on the fundamentals of human existence.

Arne Kohlweyer

contact the author print this article Save this article in PDF Send this article by mail post a comment other languages
 Links
Other articles
  • Barzakh By Mantas Kvedaravicius [en]
  • Elena By Andrei Zvyagintsev [en]
  • Play by Ruben Östlund [en]
 Tags
 Forum
2 Forum messages
  • Reply to this message

    Below Sea Level |22 February 2010 14:00, by Toniomoto

    Below Sea Level, but with plenty to drink!

    In answer to your wondering how Rosi found it easy to place his camera, I’d say that he probably did it by buying booze and drinking with his subjects, for the most part already ravaged by alcoholism. But what does that matter? Life drunk is a form of self destruction. Attaching a crypto philosophical interpretation to the isolation that alcoholism brings on it is an avoidance of the deeper issue here. Even a Marxist interpretation of the people in this film, with Water Guy and Cindy/Larry as the non-alcoholic petite bourgeoisie, would side with the alcoholics as the dross of the capitalist system, and completely miss the simple truth, too; alcoholic drinking ruins lives and the lives around them sooner or later. Rosi doesn’t really know his subject, or didn’t have the courage to face it. As such, the film doesn’t get beyond a certain social voyeurism, and is no more involved with its subject than it is philosophical. His namesake, Francesco Rosi, would have found the subject and faced it, or made no film at all if he couldn’t.

    • Below Sea Level | 3 October 2011 22:02, by Lucy
      Yes, he provided his subjects with copious amounts of alcohol. He also paid them to act in scenes that he often fabricated (usually in the early, or late parts of the day when the lighting was ideal) for his "documentary." No, he did not drink with them; he was busy running the camera - a true professional.
Reply to this article


Follow-up of the site's activity RSS 2.0 | Site Map | Login | credits & special mentions | www.nisimasa.com

Site internet: A.L, creation site internet, graphiste freelance.